Coconut Nutella Banoffee Pie

Coconut Nutella Banoffee Pie

Nutella is a frequent guest here on the Grumbling Belly and last year I combined it with another favourite, Banoffee Pie. I didn’t think it could get any better until I had a moment of inspiration a few weeks ago to add coconut and have been waiting for the opportunity to try it ever since!

One thing that makes being away from ‘home’ more enjoyable, is the wonderful community of friends we have here in Waco. From the minute we arrived, the other families in John’s PhD program completely took us under their wing and I am daily blessed by their kindness and friendships. Not many people can say that when they moved to a completely unknown part of the country, they had instant community. But, we do and I never take it for granted. One of the families recently had a great opportunity open up and they announced they were going to be leaving. This past weekend we had a lovely going away party for them which is when I decided to premiere my new twist on Nutella Banoffee Pie.

At first my biggest problem was figuring out how to best incorporate coconut without unsettling the already perfect balance of flavours. I have the hubs to thank for this one because it was his question that helped launch the genius that followed. What about a layer of coconut filling? Seeing as I have never made a coconut pie before, I thought it best to consult some southern experts and found the (near) perfect recipe thank to the Food Network and the Neelys.

Banoffee Pie is very sweet and it’s important that any additions only enhance flavour and not add more sweetness. Using my experience with banoffee pie and my small adaptations from the Neelys’ recipe, I made a couple of mini pies to get the layers and textures perfect.  I knew this pie and I would be good friends but I did not anticipate the love blossoming in my soul! In one bite you are hit with individual waves of banana, toffee, Nutella and then finally coconut. Bliss!

Coconut Nutella Banoffee 

(this makes 2 regular sized pies)

Follow Neely’s recipe  for the coconut filling (using only 1/4 cup sugar and 1 tsp of coconut extract instead of vanilla). Allow to cool.

See Nutella Banoffee Pie from April 8th 2012 for directions on making the toffee. You need about 3 cans of sweetened condensed milk, a large jar of Nutella (or 2 regular) and about 3-4 medium sized bananas.

Assembling the Pie:

Line the bottom of your favourite simple graham cracker pie shell with thinly sliced bananas.

Spoon over a layer of toffee followed by a layer of nutella (I recommend heating the nutella in a microwave safe bowl for about 1-2 minutes on 50% power so that it pours easily)

Next, pour 1/2 the coconut pie filling and gently spread across with a metal spoon trying not to ‘dig’ into the fillings underneath.

Place another layer of sliced bananas and end with a second layer of toffee. Put in fridge overnight.

Whip up some heavy cream with 1/8 cup sugar and 1/2 tsp of vanilla extract. Pipe little flowers onto the pie and drizzle over some toffee and Nutella. Finish with some toasted coconut flakes.

Coconut Nutella Banoffee Pie

This pie only gets better with time. If you can discipline yourself to wait an extra day, you will not regret it!


Nutella Banoffee Pie

Yes….I went there! Banoffee Pie is one of my all time favourites and what could make it more perfect? Only the most sumptuous and delectable flavour ever created, Nutella. We had some friends over for dinner and I was going through all the recipes I have pinned on Pinterest but just couldn’t find exactly what I was looking for and then it hit me. What I really love about baking is not so much the actual art but more the creativity it allows. There is something just so magical and rewarding in coming up with an incredible combination, specially crafted and designed for someone who you love. And so, I thought about banoffee pie and that I wanted to make something our friends had never tried before but I also thought of how everyone loves Nutella and it seemed like the most natural thing in the world to put the two together. Do not blame me if you make this and can’t stop eating it! I guarantee it will call your name from the fridge every time you walk by too closely. I recommend making it when there are others around so there are not any leftovers to torment you. It really is that good!


1 graham cracker pie shell

2 cans of sweetened condensed milk (you can use the fat-free kind here and it works just as well)

3/4 regular sized jar of Nutella

3 bananas sliced thinly

1/3 cup graham cracker crumbs

cool whip/ whipped cream for topping (optional)

To make the toffee:

Take the labels off the unopened milk cans and place in a large sauce pan of very gently simmering water. Leave for 2 hours and 30 mins. (I was making an extra-large pie so I have three cans in the picture below). The cans should remain completely immersed so you will need to top off the water every 40 mins or so as some of it will evaporate.

Take the cans out of the hot water using tongs and place into a bowl with ice water. DO NOT OPEN THE CANS UNTIL THEY HAVE COOLED OR YOU THEY WILL EXPLODE HOT TOFFEE ONTO YOUR HANDS. Leave them in the cold water for about 30 minutes or until cool to the touch. Shake the cans before opening to make sure they have cooled all the way through, empty into a bowl and stir with a fork until the toffee is a smooth consistency.

 Assembling the pie:

Coat the pie crust with a single layer of banana slices, going about 1/2 the way up the sides of the shell too.

Then place a layer of the molten toffee until the bananas on the bottom are covered.

Empty the Nutella into a bowl and microwave on 50% for 1 minute. Stir and then microwave on 50% again for another 30 seconds. The Nutella should be a smooth ‘pour-able’ consistency so it spreads smoothly. Pour all the Nutella on top of the toffee and then cover with a decent layer of graham cracker crumbs.

Place another layer of sliced bananas and then finally the remainder of the toffee. Put the pie in the fridge overnight.

 It needs this time to set otherwise when you slice a piece, all the toffee will just run out into the empty space.

Serve straight from the fridge and add cool whip/ whipped cream if you prefer.